Brown-brick apartment entrance with bronze-framed glazing, limestone base, and an autumn serviceberry beside the sidewalk.

Nassau's Station Apartments Are Leaving the Storefronts to Main Street. Mineola Shows What That Means.

At Mineola's July 8 public meeting, developer Carmine Goncalves asked the village to let him turn the ground-floor retail space at 147 Jericho Turnpike into two apartments. Mayor Paul Pereira said the village had created a zoning overlay so the empty storefront could become housing, according to Long Island Press. The same report describes the village's commercial spaces as "increasingly empty."

Mineola is the Nassau village that has had the most time to test the transit-oriented model. Pereira told Newsday in 2024 that about 1,400 new residential units had been built there since 2010, with 725 more in the pipeline. Years into that build-out, the village is still writing zoning to let storefronts leave retail use.

For anyone pricing a storefront near a Long Island Rail Road station in Hicksville, Westbury or Mineola, this matters more than the apartment counts. The new buildings are being designed with very little retail of their own. The case that new residents will support shops therefore rests on existing Main Street stock, and Mineola shows that those residents do not automatically fill it.

The retail being built is a sliver

Here is the ground-floor retail in each of the current station-area projects, divided by its apartment count.

Project Location Apartments Retail (sf) Retail sf per apartment
Westbury Commons, Gotham Organization MTA lot, Railroad Ave., Westbury 184 2,000 about 11
Cornerstone Hicksville, Terwilliger & Bartone 40 Jerusalem Ave., Hicksville 106 about 3,100 about 29
Fieldstone at North Broadway, P7 Development 76 North Broadway, Hicksville 104 4,000 about 38
Alpine Residential 99 Newbridge Rd., Hicksville 189 7,700 about 41
Eden Blue, Blue Communities affiliate 110–136 Willis Ave., Mineola 172 8,260 about 48

The three Hicksville buildings add 399 apartments over about 14,800 square feet of retail combined, or roughly 37 square feet per unit. That is a single mid-sized storefront per hundred households. Measured against the apartments it sits under, this is amenity retail, the kind of space that holds a café or a dry cleaner.

Westbury Commons is the leanest of the group. Long Island Business News reported 15,000 square feet of retail as recently as August 6. The Village of Westbury's March 19, 2026 board minutes list 2,000 square feet. The Gotham team described it as commercial space "probably restaurant usage" fronting a public plaza on Post Avenue. LIBN's September 4 story on the unanimous approval also uses 2,000 square feet. That makes it one restaurant and a plaza for 184 apartments.

The higher-density alternative was rejected

The square footage is a choice. In Hicksville, the MTA paid AECOM $973,310 to study housing at five LIRR stations. Its draft for Hicksville proposed at least 516 apartments and about 37,000 square feet of retail on Town of Oyster Bay parking lots north and east of the station, LIBN reported on August 24. That works out to roughly 72 square feet of retail per apartment, close to twice the rate of the projects actually rising near the station.

That plan is off the table. Oyster Bay Supervisor Joseph Saladino told LIBN the public wants developments "where they can be collaborators," and the MTA said it had no plans to go further. The town has already enabled more than 530 apartments completed or underway around the Hicksville station through its downtown zoning and its 2017 $10 million Downtown Revitalization Initiative grant. Investors should plan on that municipally negotiated scale, with apartment-heavy podiums, rather than on a new retail cluster at the station.

Hicksville also loses some daytime demand along the way. Fieldstone at North Broadway is going up where three multi-story office buildings and a one-story medical office building once stood. The site trades workers who bought lunch nearby for residents who commute out on the same railroad. The project topped off in September and is expected to finish next spring.

Mineola is the test that has already run

Mineola matters because the theory has been on its books for over a decade. In 2024, Pereira told Newsday the village hoped "a critical mass" of downtown residents would bring more investment. The paper described a downtown that is busy by day, driven by the LIRR station, the NYU Langone hospital on Long Island, the county court complex and office buildings, and lacking that same activity at night.

Business owners Newsday interviewed in 2024 described the same pattern. Angela Grigorakos, a manager at Spaghettini Pizza and Italian Restaurant, said, "From 12 p.m. to 2 p.m. it's a rush but then it dies down a little," and added that "a lot of places keep shutting down around here." Richard Shiu, co-owner of Franwin Pharmacy Mineola Surgical, said the village seemed to be heading in the right direction on housing but he had not yet seen much difference in his business.

Two years later, the evidence points the same way. Food openings have landed: 7th Street Burger opened its first Nassau County location at 524 Jericho Turnpike in August 2025, in the former Rex restaurant space, as Greater Long Island reported. Pastaru Pastificio operates at 133 Mineola Boulevard. At the other end of the market, 147 Jericho Turnpike is moving out of retail, and at 199 Jericho Turnpike AJM Real Estate and Burman Real Estate plan to redevelop a former Bank of America building that had sat vacant for four years. That plan has 28 apartments over about 3,000 square feet of ground-floor retail, according to LIBN.

The state is putting money behind specific blocks rather than retail generally. Mineola's $4.5 million NY Forward award funds seven projects, led by $1.3 million for Second Street and Main Street streetscape work, $1 million for the 199 Jericho Turnpike redevelopment, and $417,000 to connect the station plaza to Second Street, according to the governor's office. The pipeline also keeps adding households. Eden Blue's 172 units won preliminary Nassau County IDA approval in August, with first move-ins targeted for fall 2028 and affordability terms still under discussion at the IDA board. The Bridge, a for-sale condominium building at 212 Third St., broke ground July 29, with units priced mostly between $1 million and $2 million.

Taken together, Mineola's downtown is splitting into blocks the public money and foot paths point toward, and blocks where the best use for an empty storefront may be housing.

Westbury's design points residents at Post Avenue

Westbury Commons follows the Mineola pattern on purpose. Its one storefront faces a plaza that opens onto Post Avenue, which the Gotham team described as giving visitors a sense of "arrival" in the village. At-grade parking will be restricted to keep commuters out. Eric Alexander of Vision Long Island, who consulted on the village's station-area zoning, told LIBN that housing on the site "will benefit local businesses on Post Avenue."

So the bet sits with Post Avenue's existing owners, and the timing is long. Gotham has until March 2027 to apply for building permits, expects to break ground in the spring, and estimates about 20 months of construction after that. On that schedule, the first Westbury Commons residents arrive no earlier than late 2028. The MTA picked Mill Creek Residential Trust for this site in 2022, and that developer withdrew over rising costs.

Steady income is trading in the meantime. Advance Properties paid $5.3 million for a fully leased strip at 427 Old Country Road, with T-Mobile, Yaaas Tea and The Joint Chiropractic as tenants, LIBN reported on September 11. That is car-oriented retail with an existing rent roll, priced on today's tenants rather than on future residents.

How we would underwrite a station-area storefront this quarter

  1. Price the daytime base first. Mineola's busy hours come from the hospital, the courts and office workers. Hicksville's newest project replaced offices. Underwrite a storefront on the daytime demand that exists now, and count new residents as upside.
  2. Discount resident spending by delivery date. Fieldstone finishes in spring 2027. Westbury Commons residents arrive late 2028 at the earliest, and Eden Blue's first move-ins are targeted for fall 2028. A proforma that books that spending in year one is too early.
  3. Map the walking path, not the radius. Westbury's plaza faces Post Avenue, and Mineola is funding a station-plaza link to Second Street. Storefronts on those routes are where the planning money points.
  4. Price the residential option. At 147 Jericho Turnpike, the value of an empty storefront came from a zoning overlay that allowed apartments. Whether a similar path exists for any other site depends on village action, so confirm it with land-use counsel before it shows up in a bid. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.
  5. Expect little new competing space. With retail podiums at roughly 11 to 48 square feet per apartment, the new buildings are not adding meaningful supply against existing Main Street stock.

FAQ

Will the new Hicksville buildings compete with Broadway and Jerusalem Avenue storefronts? Only slightly. Fieldstone, Alpine Residential's 99 Newbridge Road and Cornerstone Hicksville add about 14,800 square feet of retail combined.

Is the 37,000-square-foot MTA retail plan for Hicksville still possible? The MTA told LIBN in August it had no plans to pursue further action.

When does Westbury Commons open? Groundbreaking is expected in spring 2027, followed by about 20 months of construction.

If you own or are pricing a storefront or mixed-use building near the Hicksville, Westbury or Mineola stations, Asset CRG will underwrite it on the demand that exists today and the delivery dates that actually apply. Request a Property Valuation & Off‑Market Access.

Work With Us

Our strong relationships with our clients, retailers, office tenants, the broader real estate community, and brokers offer significant benefits to property owners. We're proud to provide the most comprehensive investment sales, retail leasing, and advisory services across New York.

Follow Us on Instagram